1st one i like but at the right theres a blank spot that it has check that out take that away 8/10

2nd i like also mostly the style using a tori instead of some other thing but try adding things to the black spots nice thinking out of the cereal box :> 9/10

First one is great really nice transition form backgound to the trooper.

Second one would be as nice, but it lacks anything covering the center of the tori.

i especially like the second one best.. yet, they are both very nice. 9/10

I like it.
Remove the white blank spot on the first one
8/10
8/10

Wow, nice.
9/10 for both.

Thanks very much for the comments.
I may remove the white stripe later.

Very basic, you just took part of the render and smudged it everywhere on a black background.

4/10

i really like the second one :P its so cute