There are a number of serious flaws in your plan.
1. If we continue like we are with the same members, we will go inactive before next summer most def
2. How are we going to find new cool people if we don't give people who "seem" uncool a chance. I've learned this the hard way over the period i was leader of 2 official clans.
3. We aren't going to be totally elitist either, so there is no point on rejecting everyone unless they are already established in the community.
If we continue to wait for members of the currently quality we have, we will not grow at all.