I would have loved Fallout 3 if it wasn't so broken. Third-person animations are shit, you can get stuck if you jump behind a box against a wall and have to reload the whole game, there's a bunch of weird black artifacts in the sewers, and the textawrs are ugly.
(I tried the PS3 version, so it might be my fault.)
Also, I found Oasis without going to GameFAQs. Good times.