I know both of them are quite old, but I was wondering which one I should get since they both came out in the mac app store.

I'm leaning towards san andreas atm.

Opinions?

Both games are really good, but...

San Andreas has planes. Get it.

San Andreas as lot more things than Vice City:

You can swim
You can build muscle/agility/stamina etc.
Fighting styles.
Airplanes.
Etc.

But they are both good games.

I'd say san andreas.

More weapons.
Planes.
Fighting styles.

Perfected chaos.

Vice city is nothing in front of San Andreas. BUT! San Andreas was made by enhancing vice city which makes vice city the base of San Andreas.

Vice city had it's own fun when it first came out.

San Andreas for the win. Simply fun perfected.

San Andreas all day erry day

Even on a sunnnday.

I'll have to go with San Andreas better story, larger variety of ways to waste your time.

Looks like most people prefer san andreas. Its pretty good.