Blablabla blabla bump.

How do you rate replays ?

You just put a / and then you add a 10 on the right of the /

Then you choose your rating out of 10.

Example: 8/10

1 = Absolutely terrible
2 = Very bad
3 = Bad
4 = Below average
5 = Average
6 = Above average
7 = Good
8 = Very good
9 = Awesome
10 = Perfect

I have yet to give a 10 since i devised this clever scale. Why? Because nothing is perfect. :U

Also, AXE COP. A combination of hardcore manliness and a childs imagination.



He will chop your head off.

I don't rate them, I don't think that arbitrarily giving a replay a number out of 10 is in any way helping the person who posted it to improve. I just tell them specifically what to improve on.

Same here. Well, when I get off my ass and bother to comment. :>

8/10, would read again.

What's a comment?

What makes a good or a bad replay ?

Depends on what kind of replays we're talking about.

^
That.

Like, madman replays are supposed to contain as little grab as possible and should flow very good.