"...[not] associat[ing] clans or organisations which have not given their permission to do so"
isn't that like if eddy banned everyone for making "evo 420 blaze it" jokes?
this mod has been approved by hampa himself
Certificate of approval
So initially I edited out the "fl0w" and "TeamWushu" references and closed the thread, giving TheGod a 'verbal warning' about "...[not] associat[ing] clans or organisations which have not given their permission to do so" (there is a previous thread on which a clan/user(s) was made fun of, and so I used this as a reference for what I would do). Smilies2 then re-open the thread, having seen that I had changed these things, and I am fine with this. TheGod then edited back into the thread what had been removed (having changed the lettering slightly for some content), and so I chose to place a ban on TheGod's account. I then left a note for TheGod/Smilies2 to let them know the thread could be re-opened.
Does such a rule actually exist? I've read all the rules threads many many times, and I've never heard anything like that before. Even if you count 'hidden' rules I've never heard it.
Why would that even warrant a ban? Shouldn't it be an infraction at worst?
Either way, please link to where you got that rule from!
see it as a common sense thing
Well I mean trash talking shouldn't be banable it gives a purpose to clan enemies and at one point was encouraged on the main site until people turned to bitches.
The fact that you banned him over a rule that does not exist is absurd. The fact that you banned him over a rule that does not exist but was once endorsed when playing the game is even worse.
EDIT: Even a member of TW appreciated the mod and yet you decided that everyone there hated it and took it offensively.
The mod is funny, yes.
Trash talking isn't 'banable' if it's kept clean and in the right place(s).
It was clean, a tubeman mod made out of inspiration from team wushu and fl0w
I'm not aware of the 'rule' to which you are referring. I don't believe a rule from the past should influence the present. A ban was placed because a warning was not taken seriously, along with a user's large number of infractions.
The rule was what you banned him for, making fun of a group of people. It was clean trash talking and it was taken out of hand from you guys. trash talking was endorsed by staff at one point and then you banned him for trash talking or as you said "making fun of people" as if it offended you and your people
As above.
It was a rule you made up and never existed and shouldn't of had any infraction points, it didn't break any rules.
I don't see how a TW member's opinion that should affect the decision. If you look through the thread to which you are referring, you will see users' posts which show what the thread was being used for. I do not 'hate' it, and I do not take offense to it.
The thread showed appreciation to fl0w,fl0w2(TW), and godteam for making the mod which was a great addition to the mod list in toribash, no rules should have been broken had you not reacted so harsh to it.
The mod is funny, yes.
Trash talking isn't 'banable' if it's kept clean and in the right place(s).
It was clean, a tubeman mod made out of inspiration from team wushu and fl0w
*In the right place(s)*
I'm not aware of the 'rule' to which you are referring. I don't believe a rule from the past should influence the present. A ban was placed because a warning was not taken seriously, along with a user's large number of infractions.
The rule was what you banned him for, making fun of a group of people. It was clean trash talking and it was taken out of hand from you guys. trash talking was endorsed by staff at one point and then you banned him for trash talking or as you said "making fun of people" as if it offended you and your people
http://forum.toribash.com/showthread.php?t=430447 ; the ban reason was somewhat inexplicit, however the ban message to the user involved wasn't ; *In the right place(s)* ; that endorsement no longer exists to my knowledge ; *previous history, warned, banned*
As above.
It was a rule you made up and never existed and shouldn't of had any infraction points, it didn't break any rules.
As above.
I don't see how a TW member's opinion that should affect the decision. If you look through the thread to which you are referring, you will see users' posts which show what the thread was being used for. I do not 'hate' it, and I do not take offense to it.
The thread showed appreciation to fl0w,fl0w2(TW), and godteam for making the mod which was a great addition to the mod list in toribash, no rules should have been broken had you not reacted so harsh to it.
For which other people used to 'talk trash' ; I find the mod funny myself ; there would have been no ban had a user taken heed of a warning.