Alphanoob: i really liked the third replay, but the other two felt a bit underwhelming. it's not because they lack dms, it's because the things you did were not really all that impressive in my opinion. it feels like the replays were really safe, like you were trying to avoid doing something wrong instead of trying to do awesome stuff. i like your movement and your hits seem alright but i would just like to see more impressive things done with them. i vote no for now, you are a lot better than you were last time i looked at your replays though.
hunter: some really nice stuff in these replays, but i think they lack refinement. for example, when you approach uke in the first replay after the manip you just sorta jump up and use your leg to get the split and keep yourself from flying upwards, which makes it hard for you to hit him properly with your hands (the backhand at the end of the replay looked like a huge struggle, you hit your head on uke's torso and have to pull him awkwardly with your other hand). in this case i think you should have tried to avoid getting so close to uke.
i am also not a huge fan of the skeet on the second replay, it did not really show me that you're good at skeeting (in fact, the amount of time it took you to get the skeet off made me believe that you have a hard time getting into a good position when you want to throw things or hit uke).
the replays are good but they would be better if you tried to fix the smaller mistakes and payed more attention to the details, i feel like a lot of small mistakes mean that the replaymaker pays more attention to (for example) whether or not their kick dm'd uke rather than how it looked. i am a function over form replaymaker myself but i find it hard to ignore when something looks weird or unappealing. i vote no, but i'm pretty sure you will be good enough eventually.