Every horror game is like that if you don't immerse yourself. If you actually did do so, you would've found amnesia pretty scary. (If you dare say any other horror game scared you but amnesia didn't, you will find yourself dead the next day).

IT'S OUT

LET THERE BE SLEEPLESS NIGHTS

DOWNLOADING IT RIGHT NOW!!!! And yes, I'm gonna play through it only at night, can't start tonight though :<