left 4 dead 2?seriously , that game is more fun than scary , shooting zombies etc. not scary at all
as for silent hill , well that game is quite scary , depends on what silent hill ( 1,2,3) , didn't play most of them so i'll go only with the one i played ,shattered memories,penumbra is also scary , i heard, didn't play it though.

Like, QWOP.
Scary as hell.


Try it for yourself.

to all people saying fear and stuff is the scariest i lol'd.

obviously its amnesia the darkest decent. even an adult will run to his mother with wet pants.

i couldnt sleep for 2 days after i played it.

Silent hill is obviously the scariest, because Left For Dead isn't all that scary.

Come on, nobody thinks that QWOP is the scariest game ever ?
Ah, fuck you guys, I quit.

By the way, I have never played Silent Hill and Left 4 Dead.
That's why I don't know which one is scarier.

QWOP is totally horrifying. I don't know how I even gained the courage to click that link. *Shudder*.

Anway, out of the two it would have to be Silent hill. Played Left for dead 2 with some mates and.. didn't find it at all slightly scary. Although it was fun.

Silent hill is scarier.
But amnesia : the dark decent is way more terrifying.

lol left for dead isnt even scary , could've just compared telletubies to sumthing scary (basically what ya did)

Me neither, but you'll know after you watch a few videos ;o
Besides, Silent Hill was made to be scary, Left 4 Dead was meant to be an FPS multiplayer co-op zombie slaughter.

Silent hill is the scariest....

F.E.A.R. isnt scary lol...why you should be scared of a little girl...
you are a big solider xD