Tengo, Flash, Isolations, NutHug, Nearly, NotNoob, Internet, Dscigs, Orko, Lexx, Oblivion and Hours. The reason is because they all have some sort of unique style with there replays and it's just fun to watch.
Fatul and inoob are starting to get better really fast too.
Forgot about Marrez and Dobby.

iNoobBruh, FatulBrown, Warrior and maybe some other newer people, I love all of their styles something some other people don't have.

nearly notnoob larfen nuthug pusga

It's really hard to pick just one for me.

War_Hero and Oracle were my favorites when they were still active.

Oblivion, NutHug, and Jaker are all seemingly perfect in every way.

As far as active people go, Pusga, Eazi, and Isolations are all very impressive replay makers.

My hipster choices are Chow11, Bisonic, and Dezrai

that's like asking me to pick a favourite child

Tamer0 - very amusing style, flawless and elegant stuff and the Glimmer replay
Phoenix - very cool, very fast moves and swift hits
War_Hero - incredibly stylish and retarded speeds
Shook - just plain fun to watch
andreyoshi - super fun and quirky stuff
NotNoob - master at both default and -30, probably one of the most versatile and skilled replaymakers of all time
Nearly - perfect movement
MrJingles1 - i have no idea how he destroys uke completely and still keep a super high speed all the time
eazi - got insanely good in like a week and great at pretty much everything inside the default gravity
17april - boomhit master
Nuthug - hacking, modding and replaying combo, top 3 replaymakers of all time for me
Oblivion - realism god, top 3 replaymakers of all time for me
Larfen - manip god and flawless no grab 6 dm punch
internet - upcoming manip god and amazing at flawless stuff too
Jaker - records god and has amazing knowledge of technical shiznit
Sprytryne - boom magician and pretty good at -30 too
largekilla - insane bastard, top 3 best replaymakers of all time for me
Pulse - insane bastard
Wazz - motherfucker skeetboomed uke's torso completely
Swexx - makes some really original stuff, fantastic at both main gravities and amazing parkour
Airoblinn - incredible destruction
chamara - the biggest bro
all my opinion ofc

Zalmoxis was a big inspiration aswell for me when I was just starting, although his stuff doesn't stand out as much anymore (still very impressive though)


edit: just realised this list is big as shit, so if I were to reduce that to like 3 people I'd say Tamer0, Airoblinn and NotNoob (note that when I said the 3 people I thought were on the top 3, I meant how skilled they were. my tastes on style are different to that though.)dupbuck

pusga, dobby, internet, and hours I guess.

One of my best rpl maker is War_Hero he is THE BEST srlsly.

Zeto.

He has a very unique style and finds different ways of incorporating hits into replays, and still has a touch of realism in his replays. Instead of looking like a kung-fu maser that's been training for years, he looks like a smooth fighter just relaxed and flowing.

pusga pls
datskip pls

Nuthug- He's The best in the best for me so far, he's a guys that has a great creativity he's good at pretty much everything.

Oblivion- Another guy that has godly skills, and he has an awesome smoothing.

Jaker- He's very realistic and he's the best Bboy of toribash world

Largekilla- Great sparrer and he has the best dodges.

Swexx- Great sparrer and the best guy at parkour i ever seem.

Obazu- This guy is the best at boxing in my opinion he's punches are amazing.

And well, i have more favorites but i think showing 6 of them is enough.