That last bit is my policy already, if i'm in doubt then it's a no. Well, ideally it is. But that "no replacement" thing is a good idea, a proper replay maker isn't only good enough 3/4ths of the time. I'm not even sure i could pass the test today, but fuck, my heyday was 4 years ago.
Also, in case you missed it in the recruitment thread, replay theft now carries a ban that lasts FUCKING FOREVER. The two chaps who only got a month can consider themselves very lucky.
also i got a new mouse for my awkward left hand mousing so weeeeeeeee