Replay 1: He's a bit slow on the moves and they're not so advanced, and once he nearly executes them, Shakky's breaks him and also breaks the speed that Edu needs to hit a good move.
Replay 2: He's faster but his starter isn't too great - he opens up allowing Shakky to kick the mid-section. Edu did grab his leg, preventing him from DQ, which is good.
Replay 3: Not so bad starter, but he needs to be accurate on where he's kicking. He wins but it was just luck because Shakky couldn't stop himself from DQin'.
Overall: All starters are varied. He does different ones at different times, which means the opponent won't know what he's going to do. He's 2nd Dan Black Belt, good experience. I played him after the test and he torsoed me. He executed some good kicks and he dodged my grab. Points were very nearly equal until the last few frames - he made a break and won by 30,000 points.
My answer is a YES
Now for Shakky and KD to comment. You don't have to do it like I did, you just have to say YES/NO.
