I don't like where this is going. Sure, giving cnc is not necessary but it would be nice if given to players that are still learning replay making. Just telling him he's bad or that he didn't make the cut won't get him anywhere. I'm not bitching about how the recruiters do their job because I respect the recruiters of ORMO, I only felt like shedding some light over the fact that the more dedicated recruiter gives useful and constructive criticism to the applicants' replays. That would also make us look more serious about it IMO.
As for Desiderius, I know exactly what you mean and expecting cnc from the leading replay makers of Toribash is understandable. However, whining about it won't get you any criticism or more detailed reviews of your replays. Also, you don't expect anything from us anymore? That's kinda hurtful. It's not like we're here to write a huge wall of text about whether your replays are good or not.
In conclusion, giving cnc is not necessary but a lot of applicants would appreciate it (you don't have to write a huge essay about it) and to me it's understandable if expected from the recruiters. But please go read the original post (I'll give you a hint; it says nothing about us being bound to post cnc comments) and you losing faith in us, well, that's your loss. Thanks for applying though.