I tend to like both styles of replays, tearing uke to shreds is fun, but once in awhile a single graceful decap can be just as cool. Or something unique and unexpected. Javagamer also agrees with your point of view Dafe. I attached both styles of replays here (though my uke destruction replays are really bad).

On another unrealated note, I took dafe's "Juggle starter" and finished it up

(Incase you didn't figure it out, creative use of arm is the none uke destruction replay, and slaughter is the uke destruction)