well I'm not too sure about when it became less than "legal" however i never got in trouble for it, rather i got paid as people would often ask for ridiculous things... but to be honest alot of the time i would be making the replay's from scratch and editing the replay file to have their names, I do believe it was mostly or just private collections, if it was ever for a clan video i'd just provide a tweak to an existing replay so i don't mind. Also as i said, this was a looong time ago I doubt if you looked you'd find my old threads for it.