Okay sure FluxPony has some flaws but I think he would really make this a better clan forum-wise. Are you guys sure that someone needs in-game activity in order to join? If someone has forum activity isn't that enough?
The fact is, you're all voting on him with a biased opinion.
If he was someone you didn't know, that app would've been rejected immediately.
He didn't put any effort into the app, and ignored rules.