Owait! I get to put in my 2 cents, too?! Goody! Um...this whole topic is a mess, but to sum up how I feel about it. I think ice's scoring is a good fit in general. But to be fair, that is almost 100% RAWR's criteria. I would add a "stability" category to that as well. Clans come and go and often times are recycled of the same members. Longevity is what keeps clans like Guru, Spirit and Torigod legendary despite a lackluster ingame showing the last few years. I won't give my top ten clans (since I don't think more than 5 really meet a superb standard), but it is good to see so many people mention us. We try to keep things fun and light hearted both in game and out of. Kudos to my alpha buddies for keeping a pure vision of their clan, too. Even when they had 3 people, they never rushed a recruiting just to have "enough members" and they are one of the tightest crews in bash. Word.